@FanOfMostEverything
Forgot about that, even though I was obviously looking right at the card. I guess I’ll just have to keep my personal best at Proggy on turn 4 and bring out a Blazing Archon.
@digiman619
Nope. Same replacement ability as Progenitus, specifically to prevent these sorts of reanimation shenanigans. There’s also the matter of Old Rivalry being a sorcery, so you’d need to get around that first to bring back, say, original Emrakul (which, you’ll note, has a trigger rather than a replacement effect, so it does actually spend a little time in the graveyard.)
@FanOfMostEverything
Blightsteel Colossus will do it, though. Though you’ll likely want to spend turn one with Mountain 1/1 R that gives haste (there are a few of them)
Forgot about that, even though I was obviously looking right at the card. I guess I’ll just have to keep my personal best at Proggy on turn 4 and bring out a Blazing Archon.
Nope. Same replacement ability as Progenitus, specifically to prevent these sorts of reanimation shenanigans. There’s also the matter of Old Rivalry being a sorcery, so you’d need to get around that first to bring back, say, original Emrakul (which, you’ll note, has a trigger rather than a replacement effect, so it does actually spend a little time in the graveyard.)
Blightsteel Colossus will do it, though. Though you’ll likely want to spend turn one with Mountain 1/1 R that gives haste (there are a few of them)
Edited
Well, it would be if Proggy could stay in the graveyard.
Turn 2: Mountain, Dark Ritual, any discard effect for B, this. Apparently your nothing is an old rival to my friend Proggy.