Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Ministry of Image - Fanfiction Printing

Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!

Description

…Even in my wildest nightmares, I didn’t expect they’d go to the extreme opposite end of the spectrum and to such excesses to drive the point home. full
 
There. I fixed it. full
 
If anypony wants to use this for a story, I encourage you to do it. I want to spread this alternate headcanon as much as possible.
 


safe2175977 artist:ultrathehedgetoaster93 editor:ultrathehedgetoaster10 chancellor neighsay912 spike92453 twilight sparkle358066 alicorn314782 dragon85481 pony1604201 post season 9 story prompt9 g42030831 canterlot7161 fake screencap411 fake screenshot61 ponyville7856 portal2595 problem solved20 twilight sparkle (alicorn)149537 winged spike10137 wings223384
Source

Comments

Syntax quick reference: **bold** *italic* ||hide text|| `code` __underline__ ~~strike~~ ^sup^ %sub%

Detailed syntax guide

Tirek
Magical Inkwell - Wrote MLP fanfiction consisting of at least around 1.5k words, and has a verified link to the platform of their choice

@NexusAurora  
wow, such an old comment
 
Well, that’s why everyone has their own opinion ;-)  
I put that season behind me and despite not seeing it as canon to my fanfics, I respect the opinion of those who like that ending;-)
NexusAurora

@Tirek  
I disagree, the “worst possible not-dystopia ending” would have been the Mane six ending their friendship after Twilight’s coronation because then it would made the entire show all for nothing, hell i’d even say that the fact that they only meet once a month (wich is NOT that crazy especially for Twilight) only make this better because it show that their friendship , the one we saw grow from litteraly ep1 s1, STILL stand strong despite their distance and to me, this ending was the best ending they could have gone with.
 
@Ultra the HedgeToaster  
As for Ponyville not becoming the Capital? Eh… I can’t really explain that one but I’d guess its because Canterlot has always been seen has the central powerhouse in Equestria and besides Ponyville and Canterlot aren’t even that far, it’s meaningless to move the entire government to the near town just because your friends are there (as for Twilight’s Castle , she probally gave it to Starlight).
Tirek
Magical Inkwell - Wrote MLP fanfiction consisting of at least around 1.5k words, and has a verified link to the platform of their choice

@Ultra the HedgeToaster  
They really did something like “they only meet once a month”? That’s the worst possible not-dystopia ending ever. Twilight’s whole quest was to learn about friendship and she was sent to Ponyville because she hated the idea to leave her friends.  
Whoever wrote ep26 is an idiot and not worth being allowed to be a writer for mlp
Javarod

@Ultra the HedgeToaster  
Possibly after, or an alt-U where it happens a little before. Heck, an alternate universe story where Twilight is explaining to Luster why they’re all moving to Ponyville. Sure, the idea is late, but it’s not like someone couldn’t write it. My issue with Spike was just that he’s the friendship advisor. What’s that? Why? He was always her number one assistant, so why not seneschal? Or as I indicated, if the government is split, royalty in Ponyville, the bureaucrats that make things happen day to day in Canterlot, in sort of a management role, beneath her, but basically equal too or above everyone else.
Ultra the HedgeToaster
Wallet After Summer Sale -
Artist -

@Javarod  
So, Twilight moving the capital to Ponyville… after the epilogue future?
 
And Spike becoming her co-ruler? He did seem like the “Luna” to her “Celestia”… including the bit, where Luster just flat out ignored he was there.
 
Sounds like a good idea, if a little “late”… but better late then never.
 
@DTavs.exe  
Yeah, exactly! Twilight can canonically do a 7 pony (+1 dragon) teleport straight from her throne room in Canterlot Castle to Ponyville. Fluttershy has Discord instant-travel taxi service across the world, and she could take others. (Actually, she could take Rarity places if she needed to visit her other boutiques!)
 
Why does the episode go out of its way to say “they only meet, like, once a month”?! full
 
How’s that supposed to be a happy ending?! That’d be horrible! full
Javarod

@Ultra the HedgeToaster  
It does make sense initially, ponies prolly don’t like change, so a huge change of new ruler and new capital wouldn’t go over well. Plus how do you make it work, move the entire government to Ponyville? Give ten or twenty years, and all the details can be worked out, everypony would be used to Princess Twilight, so such a change wouldn’t be as big a deal. And it’d give Spike a better job than Friendship Ambassador, likely he’d run the Canterlot part of the government and coordinate with Twilight via dragonfire messaging.
Tirek
Magical Inkwell - Wrote MLP fanfiction consisting of at least around 1.5k words, and has a verified link to the platform of their choice

I also use a different timeline for my canon Equestria. It starts by Cozy not going to hell in season 8, but to a school for problem children. The Legion of Doom happened (because they’re a cute little family) but without “Grogar” and the princesses never retired but asked Twilight for help, so that they (the princesses) finally having some free time instead of working all the time.  
and of course the Legion of Doom are slowly getting reformed by staying together and someday accepting that friendship isn’t a bad thing.
 
 
@Background Pony #156A  
We prefer if you stop being rude.
Ultra the HedgeToaster
Wallet After Summer Sale -
Artist -

@Javarod  
Would also be an option.
 
Still. Twilight already had a castle. That castle is even still around in the future. Forcing her to move to Canterlot doesn’t make sense, especially when she is the sole ruler - doesn’t she get a say in it? full
Javarod

@Ultra the HedgeToaster  
[bq=”Ultra the HedgeToaster”] @Javarod
I’m all for your idea, the more the merrier. I was just looking for a quick visual way to convey the concept.
That it does. I kinda like the idea of Ponyville becoming the capital… Actually considering that the original castle is around the corner in the Everfree Forest, would it be a case of returning to the original capital?
anon_1515
Non-Fungible Trixie -
Notoriously Divine Tagger - Consistently uploads images above and beyond the minimum tag requirements. And/or additionally, bringing over the original description from the source if the image has one. Does NOT apply to the uploader adding several to a dozen tags after originally uploading with minimum to bare tagging.
An Artist Who Rocks - 100+ images under their artist tag
The Power of Love - Given to a publicly verified artist with an image under their artist’s tag that has reached 1000 upvotes
Hard Work - Merited Perfect Pony Plot Provider badge with only their own art
Perfect Pony Plot Provider - Uploader of 10+ images with 350 upvotes or more (Questionable/Explicit)
Artist -
Not a Llama - Happy April Fools Day!

ポニーが大好き
I was honestly surprised they didn’t just have them rule from the castle in Ponyville. They seemed to have been setting it up with the throne room and all that.
Ultra the HedgeToaster
Wallet After Summer Sale -
Artist -

@weesh  
Exactly. Drama solved.
 
I honestly thought after Twilight mentioned her move to Canterlot so casually in s9e20, with a smile on her face - literally just “throwing it out there” in the first 45 seconds of an episode that wasn’t even about her leaving (which honestly completely destroyed that entire episode for me since that was all I could think about the entire time watching it) - that the reason was simply that the writers had a quick-fix for it.
 
And COME ON, they brought this up in season 8! It was OBVIOUS! >_<#
 
…Of course, not to mention: TWILIGHT ALREADY HAD HER OWN CASTLE! IF SHE’S THE RULER OF THE LAND, SHE SHOULD FREAKIN’ GET TO DECIDE WHERE SHE’D RULE FROM! >_<#
 
 
Aaagh! This makes no sense! >____<#####
Ultra the HedgeToaster
Wallet After Summer Sale -
Artist -

@Javarod  
I’m all for your idea, the more the merrier. I was just looking for a quick visual way to convey the concept.
 
 
 
@Background Pony #A0E5  
Didn’t I say “lunch break” in the picture? ;)
 
This way, Twilight could literally visit Ponyville as easily as if Ponyville was the next room over. :D
 
Otherwise, the implication is that Celestia and Luna both dumped their responsibilities, combined, on one pony, Twilight. And that’d be just unfair to her, especially after they went on and on in s9e13 about how much they wanted “out of the golden cage”. :(
Javarod

If this is a reference to Twilight ruling from Canterlot, my question is why does she have to? Sure, for the first few years I can see it, but since most of the actual running of the country is no doubt done by paper pushers who don’t need immediate access to the princess, once things get settled, Twi could easily move the capital to Ponyville. Also don’t you think Luna & Celestia (best princess first nat’) will get bored and want to move back to Canterlot?
Background Pony #F10B
Celestia could teleport from Ponyville to Canterlot in “Lesson Zero”. Twi did likewise in “A Royal Problem”.
 
It’s not a problem of physical distance, it’s they’re being too busy with their new responsibilities to have more time together. Quick travel wouldn’t change that much.