Unpopular opinion but immersion is a stupid argument when talking about video games. Immersion doesn’t necessarily mean that you feel like you were there. I was immersed in Assassin’s Creed Brotherhood but I never once imagined myself in Rome, I just lost track of time.
I hate people who use immersion as if it’s the make-or-break factor. It’s so subjective and everyone has a different idea and experience. That’s like saying a specific dish in a restaurant is bad because you dislike it’s taste, even though other people do like it.
I can hate a lot of people. In fact, I hate people that fuck up games with unnecessary identity politics but I also hate people that fuck it up with their pandering and “accuracy” bullshit. Piss off, you gate-keeping elitist fucks.
I play games because I want to be entertained. I don’t expect some deep thought-provoking crap, especially when I don’t care much about it. But if it’s there and it entertains me, then it succeeds.
A game that fails to entertain, regardless of the method, design and reason, is not a game. It’s a chore.