Here’s a paraphrase from the Wrestling Observer Newsletter of the All Out fight investigation, which Meltzer says has been included.
• The investigation was completed last week and ended with Chris Guy (Ace Steele) being let go, the buy-out talks with Punk, and the imminent return of The Elite.
• The Elite and Don Callis were backstage at the show in Norfolk, but did not appear on TV. Dave speculates that Full Gear would be a logical point for their return, but says nothing has actually been said or hinted to him as to when they might truly be back on TV.
• Many top stars (including Jericho) believe that Punk will not be back. One top star was quoted as saying Punk’s value on screen isn’t worth the hassle and dark cloud he brings backstage.
• A recap of the fight: The Bucks and AEW Head of Legal Megha Parekh went to Punk’s locker room to discuss the press conference. There were various versions claiming the Bucks kicked the door down, which didn’t happen. Punk punched Matt Jackson, Guy hit Nick Jackson with a steel chair and bit Kenny Omega on the arm.
• Dave recounts the Nick Hausman story about Punk and his dog and says that the obvious problem with the story is that there is no way this wouldn’t have surfaced almost immediately, yet in almost 7-8 weeks, it never came up, and only came up when news of The Elite’s return got out. Dave has quotes from several sources, including one not affiliated with either side (but who eventually became pro-Elite), that the whole dog story is a complete lie. According to this source, Punk couldn’t give a fuck less about the dog and was a complete psycho, Kenny picked up the dog to protect it and gave it to Megha who was then holding the dog and screaming at Punk to stop. Punk still didn’t stop.
• Dave says there were lawyers involved almost immediately from all sides, but as of right now, there has been no legal action and The Elite decided not to press charges.
• Dave says that usually the biggest star in a company would have the advantage, but even though in this case at least most of the top stars sided with The Elite, the investigation did clear The Elite and Chris Guy was fired and Punk is not coming back. He says there haven’t been any actual talks with WWE and Punk because legally he’s still under AEW contract at the moment and so they can’t do that yet.
• Dave notes that obviously people on Punk’s side won’t change their feelings regardless of this outcome of the investigation, but he says that the whole situation should have been handled way back, even before Page’s promo about workers’ rights, when the Cabana situation (removing him from AEW and putting him in ROH) first happened and negativity about Punk began to rise among people in the locker room.
It was also reported by Fightful that after Punk’s presser, when he told people if anyone got something to say to him meet up with him, Jericho went up to him and told Punk that he was a cancer to the locker room and a detriment to the company. Punk allegedly responded by saying it’s none of his business.