For your consideration… love magic.
So I’ve been thinking a lot lately about the different types of magic present in Equestria, and Frustration in Excelsis’s
comment from yesterday about love caught my attention because it ties into something I’ve been contemplating for a bit.
Similar thing with changelings and love. They don’t digest it, but need to be “saturated” with love energy for their biology to work.
This idea, that love magic is somehow a requirement for certain lifeforms to maintain their biological functions, actually has some canonical basis. Specifically, there’s a brief line in the season seven episode “To Change a Changeling” where Starlight reveals why the plants surrounding the changeling hive are coming back.
Starlight Glimmer: “But now that the changelings don’t feed on the love of everything around them, plants have started to grow back.”
And that got me thinking… love magic seems at once very powerful, and fairly elusive in the world of Equestria. There are some clear signs that Princess Cadance has the ability to use it, but as far back as her wedding episode there have also been indicators that it’s a pretty rare ability for her to have.
Twilight Sparkle: “How many unicorns can just spread love wherever they go? I only know of one!”
I feel it stands to reason that if there
were other notable users of love magic in the world (or historically), Twilight would be one of the few who would know about it. Yet with the added information of it being something suffused in the living things of Equestria, it occurred to me that while active use of the variety Cadance can manage might be uncommon, there is one group of ponies who may be unconsciously using it all the time.
That is to say, what if the long contemplated magic of the earth ponies is actually love magic?
It makes a lot of sense when you consider it that way. Next to her family and closest friends, Applejack loves Sweet Apple Acres and every tree in it. Every day she pours love into it, and in doing so imparts the essence of life, biologically sustaining magic, into the trees and surrounding area.
But beyond that, there are other things that idea helps clarify as well. Potions, for instance. Any confusion over Zecora’s various magical elixirs (and their predominant use for growing and healing) make a lot more sense if every plant in Equestria contains some tiny essence of magical, life sustaining energy. And the use of love magic to grow might explain another, somewhat controversial issue… Twilight growing food.
Twilight, after all, is the element of magic, and I have long suspected her to be (as a result of that distinction) one of the few ponies who can harness most if not all of the varieties of magic that exist in Equestria. Given that she’s demonstrated some ability to use love before (albeit disastrously)…
… the idea that she may be one of the few active magic users who can grow plants is not that farfetched.
On a final note, there is another thing this idea explains, namely why love magic is so secretive, and why it might not be discussed as much as something ponies can learn. We’ve twice seen incidents where the magical powers of love (curious things that they are) have completely subsumed another pony’s way of thinking. Twilight only twisted love a little, and the result was obsession and madness. The CMC messed with love, and came within a hair of inextricably linking Big Mac and Cheerilee together to the exclusion of everything else they ever cared about. In short, messing with love magic is messing with the power it has over life itself, and a significant mistake could be devastating.
We were all wrong. This is the timeline where Cadance went evil.