I’m not sure if I like Pinkie Swarm the most. I feel like Pinkie was kind of at fault for not trying to explain herself better. I mean she was eating those cakes for Celestia, she didn’t give any indication she was taking things seriously. She wasn’t doing herself any favors.
Though I will admit the rest of the Mane Six probably should have at least wondered if Pinkie had a point they just weren’t understanding and ask her to be specific. So it was kind of their fault too in a way.
I think both parties should have learned a lesson. For Pinkie Pie it should have been a lesson on trying to get people to understand, believe me I know where she’s coming from, sometimes you don’t communicate correctly. But it’s something that’s very valuble in society.
I got to admit I think Season 1 Pinkie Pie was not handled the best. I wish her friends were both more assertive but also more understanding. I feel like they treat her like a child who can’t be corrected. She’s still an adult! She should neither be given a free pass for not explaining correctly nor ignored outright.