General Tag Discussion

@Zeb  
Thanks!

With context to the images tagged so far, what is the difference between nonconsensual and rape? They seem to be the same at a glance to the images tagged.

@Background Pony #A8E1  
I don’t know if this was the intent of the tag, but it looks like nonconsensual has application on actions that aren’t sex and technically would be out of the scope of the rape tag.
 

 
If that’s the case then, the tag is in serious need of clean-up.

@Background Pony #A8E1  
Nonconsensual just seems to be used for when, well, something is happening that the recipient doesn’t want.  
I don’t think it needs to be directly tied to rape since that is already covered by the rape tag itself.

@Zeb  
Then there’s also bad touch

General question about alias / implication requests and suggestion threads in this forum:  
I realize mods also have other things to do but is there like a guideline for how long it usually takes until such threads get answers and decisions? Or the other way around, is there a time after which it means that this alias / implication is not needed and will not happen?
 
Or should we bump “older” threads that got no official answer / final verdict yet, as they might just have been missed in the flood or forgotten about?

@Background Pony #257A
 
Bumping a thread that nobody is subscribed to is unlikely to get a response, but if a few days go by it doesn’t hurt to post in this thread pointing to the request.

@cheezedoodle  
There are a few on page 2
 
This one  
for example, trying to figure out what to do with “full comic” / “all in one” / “compilation”
 
Or likely easier to decide: the relationship between pool and swimming pool

Anyone know if we have a tag for the flowery wedding arch thing? Like in this image:  

 
There’s a tag wedding arch [NSFW], but it’s only on a single image set. So I’m wondering if there’s another tag that’s being used.

@Zeb
 
It’s an arbor, which is an arch-shaped trellis, so I would probably have arbor imply trellis and maybe flowers.

Just checking. Images where the characters shown are ambiguously pony should have barely pony related or is there something else they could be tagged/filtered with?
 
Example >>2109322 (Explicit)
 
I know this OC is an anthro pony, but judging the image on the image’s attributes would make me think this is just two generic furries.

All righty, I finally got around to sorting out those cross-fandom tags I was talking about a while ago – here. I sorted them by how many images there are under each, in a transparent attempt to pass the buck on the decision of how many hits does such a tag need to have before it’s worth the effort of being given implications and so on.

Bronycon needs to now also be implied by Bronycon 2019

@Frustration in Excelsis  

What do you think about tag “based on other artist work”? I am not sure in my English, and I am not sure that there is no already such tag.  
There is tag “redraw”, but is ambiguous and don’t assume large additional work, with additional background/lining/coloring/composition of parts.
 
There is tag “collaboration”, but it is not collaboration in strict sense, because most likely original artist don’t know about the works with someone else. Also I don’t feel photo of printed work is collaboration in any sense.
 
There is tag “edit”, but it does assume just very basic manipulations, keeping large part of original work pixels
 
Examples  
>>1751447 ( lining/coloring sketch with additional background )  
>>1265440 ( lining/coloring sketch )  
>>1634924  
Actually almost all works under tag artist:kp-shadowsquirrel in last two years aren’t his original drawings
 
Maybe “collaboraton” tag is enough for these, but in very wide sense actually almost all works are collaborations based on some references

@xbi  
In the case of KP-shadowsquirrel, at least for the 3D stuff, that artist tag is used because their original 3D models are in the image and used, at the very least, as a base.
 
I think that’s a common thing for 3D models - the artist of the 3D model is tagged if known, even if the modeler didn’t assemble, pose, or animate the scene.

@mjangelvortex  
The “stupid sexy __” tags do need a serious trim.  
@mjangelvortex  
The word “sexy” is not Suggestive; it’s an exact synonym for “attractive”, which is clearly Safe.
 
@Background Pony #257A  

 
@Dogman15  
Please note we have a specific thread for ratings discussion.
 
@PlotHole  
If it’s just like, a slight dip in the panties or a single line on them, it’s Suggestive. Questionable is for when you start getting extra details on it.  
@cheezedoodle  
The bulletpoint itself is for them combined, to place that combination in Suggestive. If it’s lower than low-detail, it doesn’t exist, and if it’s not prominent (like if it were Sunset’s tiny details in the background of an image of Flash), it’s Safe, though that’s rare.
 
Also, again, we have a specific thread for ratings to try to not clog up this one, and it’s barely-used.
 
@saby  
A while back I was trying to kill “bad touch” outside of the memes, cause otherwise it’s _completely redundant with “molestation” with a more muddled meaning to boot.

Is there a way to search for tags, so I can more easily sieve through the aliased section? Sometimes, I can only remember part of a tag, often a latter word, and I can’t find it.

@Beauvoir Ferril  
https://derpibooru.org/tags and go <part of tag>* maybe? For instance, “*cloud” to search things ending in cloud.

@Beauvoir Ferril
 
Also google search often works for misspelled or synonymous tags, for example google search “derpibooru this will end in moon”

tubby wubby pony waifu  
Is this needed, or can it be removed?

@Background Pony #A8E1  
It looks like just another fat tag for Rainbow Dash. I don’t know why it’s existed for this long, but it seems completely unnecessary.

It was also a horrid cringeariffic song that was bafflingly popular in the Middle Fandom Era.

@Background Pony #A8E1  
@Background Pony #D326  
@TexasUberAlles  
From what I remember it was one of the songs sung in the Rainbow Dash Presents episode for My Little Dashie.  

 
So only applicable to like, 3 images under the tag. At most.  
Probably not needed at all.

@Background Pony #A8E1  

 
Huh. It actually works. Thanks, fella. ^^