Rating tags general

@Frustration in Excelsis  
Without reading the description, it looks like an odd-eyed pony with a recent-ish scar from facial burn. Wouldn’t personally tag the picture any degree of grimdark.

@Frustration in Excelsis  
The description never matters for tagging save maybe insights into artist intent. Safe.

Is this really safe? Oppal and Winona’s names are in the background and spike has an evil look on their face. Spike looks like he murdered them.

@Chibi dragon lord  
That link just goes to a page.

@Dragonpone  
Sorry, I was talking about this image.

@Chibi dragon lord  
Yes, that’s safe. Implied violence is fine, and even moderate shown violence.

@GenericArchangel  
Again, apike also has an evil smile on his face. I’m sure there’s no other reason he would be that happy being at a graveyard.

@Chibi dragon lord  
The image does not qualify for semi-grim dark. It meets none of the criteria.

@GenericArchangel  
Okay, whatever you say.

@Chibi dragon lord  
Keep in mind that the show itself has Pinkie clones being zapped to implode into magic, the Mean 6 being melted to death, and Sombra being rended very quickly, so even murder itself requires at the very least some pain or mild bodily horror to trigger Semi-grimdark.  
We don’t see a thing here except gravestones; for all we know, Spike poisoned them in ways their hearts would just give out in their sleep.

 
But if grotesque and grimdark are ratings, I don’t see why vulgar and slur aren’t ratings. They still describe the content like those other two.

@Liggliluff  
To be a rating other than Safe, something must encompass a broad concept of kinds of content not suitable for children, and for such unsuitability to be agreed on enough that we forbid it being meshed with Safe. Vulgar and slur are too narrow, and are generally not thought of as being entirely unsuitable for children.

@Chibi dragon lord  
Suggestive.

@GenericArchangel  
Thought so.

Does telling someone to “bend over” count as suggestive?
 

@Damaged  
I think so (there’s a whole Rarity meme about this and I’ve always seen it rated Suggestive), although I’m not entirely sure anymore since there’s a whole host of Safe-rated innuendo I’ve become aware of.

@Damaged  
@Princess Luna  
I’d tag it as suggestive just to be on the safe side of things.

@mjangelvortex  
That might be all well and good normally, but we are here in the actual thread to figure out ratings for some consistency; dragging in practices like that to actual determinations ruins consistency.

Need some help figuring out what’s visible in this:  
 
Uploader tagged “explicit” but I’m not seeing definition of anatomy in the loose painty style.

@Background Pony #2909  
I only see nipple. So I’d tag it as questionable.

@Background Pony #2909  
Some people think that nipples are Explicit, cause they don’t read the tag guidelines. Common problem, seems Questionable to me.

Safe or suggestive?  
>>2218026

@Background Pony #6691  
Looks like it’s Suggestive to me.

@mjangelvortex  
Same