Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Pony Arts & Prints!

Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!

Description

No description provided.

safe2174327 artist:moenkin155 lucky clover701 princess cadance40049 twilight sparkle357738 wild fire947 alicorn314120 earth pony446313 pegasus496477 pony1602467 unicorn537911 a canterlot wedding3669 g42028879 argument1139 background pony12290 bad end2803 cadance is an idiot7 comic135426 crying55471 dialogue92990 female1802670 filly97362 filly cadance177 filly twilight sparkle3443 foal44180 fridge horror189 fridge logic71 holding leg230 love6732 love spell33 magic96625 male550708 mare741025 mind control4781 oops694 ponies standing next to each other221 proud607 reality ensues517 scene interpretation10886 stallion195681 table13072 teen princess cadance1153 the implications are horrible363 unfortunate implications213 unicorn twilight33201 whoops137 young1944 young twilight29 younger22844

Comments

Syntax quick reference: **bold** *italic* ||hide text|| `code` __underline__ ~~strike~~ ^sup^ %sub%

Detailed syntax guide

CORDZ2000
Solar Hero - Went above and beyond for the Solar Deity, drawing from the power of the sun itself to bring balance to the fight against the Lunar Insurrection (April Fools 2023).

Draconequues Lover zcord
In honestly even if they weren’t married to someone else, couples have arguments. In even if they were falling out of love, that’s not up to u. Let things be, u shouldn’t force two people or ponies in this instance to still love each other if they don’t.
Posted Report
N2MP

@Tide Hunter  
Oh, I agree it’s fun to joke about. There was another version by a different artist where they were brother and sister, or with Shining Armor and Fleur (Fancy Pant’s girlfriend) arguining over one of them tripping over the other and both getting covered in mud and Cadance getting pissed even though she just forced them into it. That’s why you shouldn’t mess with love.
Tide Hunter
Non-Fungible Trixie -
Wallet After Summer Sale -
Birthday Cake - Celebrated MLP's 7th birthday
Artist -

Tag the genders
@N2MP  
Yeah, but it’s fun to joke about.  
Also,  
with the guy saying she’s not because he’s already paid for 3 this month.
 
It seems like, even if they aren’t in a relationship, it would certainly be his business if he’s paying for it.
N2MP

I think everyone is forgetting the context of their argument. The girl wants to go the spa for a hooficure, with the guy saying she’s not because he’s already paid for 3 this month. She also mentions that all her girlfriends are getting theirs done.
 
So clearly they’re not strangers. And if they were just friends or related what place does the guy have to tell her she’s not going? It wouldn’t be his business.
 
The only logical thing you can take from this scene is that they’re in a relationship, because the dialogue sounds like a couple arguing over money because of joint finances.
Background Pony #F452
@Background Pony #C7F5  
Hmm, those things? The specifics on how they work, I don’t know, but assuming they are indeed mind controlled or something similar, I’d say they wouldn’t be able to be compelled to hurt or betray someone they were close to.
 
So, like, it would work on strangers and such, but if ordered to hurt their lover or something, there’s no way it’d ever work, the power of friendship or love would allow them to break free. It’s not that mind control is impossible for someone as evil as Sombra, it’s that the friendship or love and bonds between people will easily overcome it, so they’d never take an action that would betray or hurt someone they were close to.
 
For pitting tons of strangers against other strangers, it would be a fairly effective but incredibly cruel army, but it wouldn’t ever work on making friends or lovers hurt or betray each other. It puts Sombra at an immediate disadvantage, because if any of them came into contact with or saw a close friend or lover, they’d inevitably end up breaking free. You know, kind of like how Cadance broke Shining free from the trance he was in, and the power of love proceeded to throw out a changeling army.
 
You’re right that the whole alternate universe shown there is in very, very bad shape though, and all sorts of things were messed up. Friendship and love couldn’t ever ‘break’ or anything, and would still ultimately overcome, and I’m sure good will inevitably triumph even there, but it’s still a world thrown into chaos and there’s plenty of disarray.
Background Pony #F452
@Background Pony #C7F5  
Sombra seems to mostly make use of straight up slavery and subjugation, not mind control. Either way, regardless of what it is, it can and will be broken. In the case of slavery and stuff, the alicorns and others aren’t going to tolerate it, and mind control can be overcome by friendship or love.
Background Pony #580C
@Background Pony #C7F5
Anyway, the magic, power and strength of friendship and of course, especially love is a central theme of the series, nobody is going to be torn away from the one they love and share a bond with in some sort of awful bad end by some freak grimdark mind control nonsense, end of story.
 
…Other than the ponies under Sombra’s mind control. For example.
Background Pony #F452
@Background Pony #C7F5  
The point is that it wouldn’t work on ponies who already love someone. Their love, bond, relationship, and so on, would be so much stronger than it and all.
 
Besides, Cadances spell obviously wasn’t even some sort of grimdark mind control/brainwash spell in the first place. It was more of a little, gentle ‘nudge’ to help the two ponies with their quarrel, no destruction of free will involved. I wouldn’t even begin to compare it with that love potion, because there’s no comparison to be made, though it also wouldn’t work on ponies who love someone, mind you. Other things could be said about the love potion, but I want to keep this post brief.
 
Anyway, the magic, power and strength of friendship and of course, especially love is a central theme of the series, nobody is going to be torn away from the one they love and share a bond with in some sort of awful bad end by some freak grimdark mind control nonsense, end of story.
 
I hope that answers your question. I tried to keep this post briefer than it could have been, as I don’t feel so well right now.
Background Pony #580C
Considering love potions are a real thing in Equestria, I don’t see why this here shouldn’t be possible. I mean, I understand the need to deny it so one can sleep better, of course… but that’s all it is, really.
Spiritus Arcane
Solar Supporter - Fought against the New Lunar Republic rebellion on the side of the Solar Deity (April Fools 2023).
Wallet After Summer Sale -
Not a Llama - Happy April Fools Day!
The End wasn't The End - Found a new home after the great exodus of 2012

@Softy  
In this context it kinda sets up something really tragic, in that the two weren’t actually happy with their current relationships and Cadance’s spell let them express their true love for each other…
Background Pony #F452
@KentuckyFriedScootaloo  
Nah, no way. Besides, loyalty is extremely important, among other things. It’d be extremely disgusting if someone just up and abandoned their lover, though obviously the spell in this comic is being portrayed as some sort of grimdark brainwashing spell or something.
 
Like I said though, don’t really want to go into it, or otherwise be forced to post more ranting.
deactivated9659a69

This is why you can’t assume that two ponies who happen to be somewhere together are a couple. They could have been friends, or maybe just two ponies who have never met before who started talking to each other, or maybe they’re siblings. Who knows?
Background Pony #F452
@Background Pony #3E18  
Eh, it comes off as harsh because I didn’t want to understate things. I find stuff like this to be really, really high on the grimdark scale, even if it simply isn’t possible and would never happen.
 
Not really an insult to the artist or anything, as completely outrageous, grimdark, or silly (or a mix of all of those) stuff gets drawn all the time, it’s just that this one I found particularly dark and depressing, and as an extension of that I went more out of my way to mention how it isn’t a possibility.
 
You get the idea, I guess.
 
@Ifreann  
We’re talking about the world of MLP, where magic is real, and it’s not even remotely realistic there either. As I said, if the ponies already had lovers, it simply wouldn’t ever work on them, because their love and bond and all that is so much stronger.
 
Anyway, whatever, didn’t really intend for this to be a whole conversation, so I’ll likely be going now.