Clickspoilers + disabling voting from SPOILERED thumbs

1. Static:  
    
   This is basically how they are now
    
2. Click:  
    
   (yeah, shitty gif, I know). Basically, you click the thumbnail (galleries only) once to unspoiler the pic, then click again to go to the actual pic. If you move the mouse out (or on mobiles, click something else I guess), it becomes spoilered again, and you have to click-to-unspoiler again.
    
3. Hover:  
   Much like Click, but unspoilers when you move the mouse into it, spoilers when the mouse leaves it again. Useless on mobiles. You’ll have to learn to mouse around things by the warnings given in the black bar alone. Do not use this if you often rely on the mouseover tags (use click or normal instead).
    
4. Text:  
    
   (ignore that fluttermac is tagged trixie) “Hmm, I found this artist that has 70% questionable, but I don’t see any grimdark warnings. I’d like to see the thumbs and decide if I watch it or not” This does exactly that, but still keeps the black bar.
    
5. Off:  
    
   Effectively disables all spoilered tags in your filter, without having to maintain two filters.
    
   The idea (well, my idea) is to have it a dropdown a la the Filter menu: when you change it it redirects to the page you were on etc. so that you can switch real quickly. I know that at least TSP wants to make click the default.
    
   –
    
   Disabling voting on SPOILERED thumbs  
   Brings back memories to a while back, no? Anyway, a keen eye will have spotted two particular things in the above images:  
6. Spoilered images did not have the yellow background  
7. In all modes (except “off” of course), the fave, up- and downvote buttons were slightly grayed out. An ever keener eye would have also seen how it still indicates if you have something that is spoilered faved/up/downvoted, too.
    
   Because there was such a drama over the downvote button last time, we can do a few things. NOTE: you will always be able to vote from the image page itself! If you have already voted, you can always undo your vote from the thumb as well!  
8. Disable both faving and voting on spoilered thumbs (excluding “Off”)  
9. Disable faving and voting in only some modes (discuss!)  
10. Disable only downvoting on spoilered thumbs. _{We know who you are. For the ones who don’t know, there’s a bunch of users out there that instead of hiding things like they’re supposed to, they spoiler them so that they can downvote every single spoilered pic they ever see. I do not care about these users. FYI the reverting of the removed downvote button a while back was because of the few legit reports about untagged shitmemes, not because of the [whining intensifies] shitposting loudly mass-downvoters}
     

1. Disable faving/voting from “static” spoilers  
2. Disable downvoting from everything with a black bar (ie, everywhere but “Off”)  
   My reason for this is that I’ve been using hover-spoiler through scripting for a while now, so when I unspoiler something that I like, I can fave it. However, being a ‘normal’ user also means that if I don’t like it, I just move on; it’s not like the spoiler warned me that I might not like it after all (or looking at score first, etc).
    
   So discuss!

I think the click behavior might be the most sensible. Changing the image on hover creates excessive annoying flashing and visual clutter.

As long as spoilering something does not load the thumbnail, I’m fine with practically anything. Except with not being able to upvote spoilered images :-(

The idea is that you can choose what you want to use

you mean upvote based on tags

the reverting of the removed downvote button a while back was because of the few legit reports about untagged shitmemes

Personally my preference towards the fave/vote business is as follows:

1. Disable faving/voting from “static” spoilers
2. Disable downvoting from everything with a black bar (ie, everywhere but “Off”)