What a horrible fate…

Only to get stoned a few hours later.  
Too bad so sad.

Starlight is used to this
 

Starlight’s tounge and horn will make this the best sybian EVER

“Two words for you Starlight. Shrinking and buttplug.”

Sadly only then then Chrissy find out Starlight brought a can of Raid.

@Background Pony #B9C3  
A mix of both is quite possible, I agree.
 
And very true. It’s always gonna be bad, though i’ll still argue (or at least guess) that being raped by your non-preferred gender would probably magnify the already strong emotional reaction significantly.

@Dark Vessel
 
Either way, Chrysalis said something like an “eternity for taking revenge.”
 
I’d imagine it isn’t at all implausible she had some torture planned down the line for her, before it all went to shit.
 
Possibly was planning on making the Royal Sisters suffer too, depending on how much she hates them, and how much they pissed her off with that distraction. Starlight, Celestia, and Luna were all thrown into the same “cell” after they were all defeated, separate from the others, I noticed…
 
Gender doesn’t matter that much, in any case. You’re still getting raped.

This is my headcanon. What else would a succubus-alike do to take revenge on her greatest foe? Bonus points: Both are female, Starlight is unlikely to be attracted to her, which will only make the revenge stronger.

I can’t imagine this would be consensual.
 
And I imagine that Starlight wouldn’t be the only one to get… attention.
 
One wonders what she might’ve done in the unknown length of time that Cadance was being impersonated…
 
(I’m not implying he’d be “lucky,” at all. Neither would Starlight)