Sweet F.A.
Alright, so. My final thoughts on The Dragon Prince Book Four. (I’m going to be making a video review of this where I’ll get more into my feelings about the season but here’s a quick summary.)
I… really thought this season was mid. Unfortunately a lot of the problems that plagued the first episode of the season continued through the rest of it. One of the big issues was that it felt rushed, and admittedly that was a problem with a lot of the rest of the show due to the relatively short seasons–nine episodes with 24 minute each isn’t the best length for a show that’s supposed to tell a large, epic story. If the show wants to continue in the future, it needs space to breathe, because right now, everything feels rushed and underdeveloped. The episodes really feel like they need to be substantially longer—anywhere from 10-20 minutes more.
But at least in the previous seasons, the scenes were cut in such a way that we could still immerse ourselves into each one. There were some really wonderful moments in Book Four, but the show needs more screen time to let us enjoy them properly. The episodes in this whole season were constantly switching between points of view. Some scenes wouldn’t even last two minutes. It comes across as the directors being scared to fully immerse us in any one scene, like they want to create cheap and artificial tension by constantly leaving us on minor cliffhangers without actually letting us enjoy the scene and characters within it for the tension to build up naturally and the cliffhangers to feel meaningful.
Series creator Aaron Ehasz said that he wanted this season to be darker than the previous ones and continue the trend started by Book Three, and there were elements here and there where I could see that. But for as dark as it was, it fell back way too hard on the humor , which has taken a downturn. Not like humor was ever the high point of the show, but far too much time gets spent on very juvenile jokes like the farting and feet jokes I’ve already complained about when the episodes don’t have enough time to show us the interesting things as it is, which makes it doubly frustrating. The show as a whole feels much more juvenile, in fact. Group laughter and sighs and reactions after every minor event, combined with the bad jokes, all contribute to making it feel like it’s aimed at a younger audience than seasons 1-3.
Even aside from all that, the writing is not as good as previous seasons. In addition to the series itself feeling rushed in-universe, Book Four feels like it was rushed to be released. It took three years to make, but still feels like it needed another pass. Characters feel awkward and stilted and do things that make no logical sense. The season also has a very bad habit of telling the audience about things, not showing us. The biggest example of both of these is Rayla and Callum’s arc. The fact that Rayla ran away is something fans would only know if they had read the side comic Through the Moon, and without that knowledge, throughout the season their bickering just feels really awkward and stupid. The timeskip is a fine concept, but we need to be shown the important things, not have them relegated to subpar comics. Way too much important context is relegated to them. Apparently the whole thing with Ezran’s crown and Rayla’s blades came up in side comics. Ditto for the Orphan Queen, who plays a not insignificant part in the season. Some really critical information that’s never explained in the show, and leads to it feeling much more lacking. The comics are nice for the superfans, but not for more casual viewers. It would have been far more interesting to actually see what happened in Through the Moon, Claudia’s journey through Xadia, her meeting Terry, as well as have the main characters make the discoveries of Aaravos and Umber Tor themselves. As it is, they just feel insignificant.
Speaking of, as someone who was a fan of Rayla and Callum in previous seasons, I really disliked this one. Fans were talking about looking forward to Rayllum angst before this season dropped, and having seen it, if this is the angst people were talking about… I don’t get it? I was really hopeful about Rayla and Callum after Book Three, because they got together at the end of it and I was excited to see what would happen with them already a couple this early on. I wanted to see them be a badass power couple who fought evil together… instead, the show just turned them into every other TV couple. The couple that gets together and then breaks up, and that the show still spends a lot of time trying to convince us that they need each other, but we come away from it thinking that they need counseling? (So in other words, Peter and MJ from Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man trilogy.)
I don’t even know why this show feels the need to fall back on cliched relationship drama when it already has enough sources of tension within the plot. Aaravos is rising up and tensions between the humans and Xadians are rising again, I don’t want to focus on Callum’s squabbles with Rayla. But nooo, they need a forced conflict! They need to have something to do this season! They could’ve had a conflict about duty, with Rayla being opposed to Callum being so interested in the same mirror that corrupted Viren, or Callum being frustrated or afraid (which turns into anger) at the fact that Viren’s corpse or Claudia weren’t found and Rayla gave up on looking for them, or even their societies frowning upon the elf/human romance and them having to power through it. But no, they need a forced romance fight where they break up even though it’s clear they’re going to get together again in the end.
The result is a season that’s not awful, but doesn’t come close to living up to either the expectations we had of it, or more importantly, the potential of all the pieces it has to play with. So it gets a 6/10.