General Tag Discussion

@TexasUberAlles  
Honestly, I only know him for Silent Movie, which I started watching halfway though (still need to get around to watching the first half).

Why does “battery game” imply “birthday game” when there’s only one picture tagged “battery game”? Shouldn’t implications require more than one picture?

Anyone noticed how a lot of EQG image of Twi have the alicorn tag on them when it’s an image of the normal human look and not even with wings or anything?  
I also noticed it tends to be added later by a BP.  
That’s counted as mistagging isn’t it?

@Prof.NightJack  
Yeah that’s mistagging.

@Prof.NightJack  
Maybe people are adding the princess twilight tag (not realizing the proper purpose of the tag and/or not realizing it was changed), which is now twilight sparkle (alicorn), which implies alicorn. I dunno.

Shouldn’t food art imply food? Or is there a reason why it doesn’t
 
I honostly haven’t looked through enough to know if it probably does or not… but it would seem that food art should imply food since it’s art about food, right?

@Rainboom Dash  
I don’t support a medium tag implying the components of the medium, that would mean a lot of useless tags:  

@saby  
It makes sense not to have something like 'oil painting' imply 'oil paint', since we’d probably never see 'oil paint' unless it was in an 'oil painting'. But 'food' vs 'food art' doesn’t quite fall into that same logic; 'food' can be used outside of the context of 'food art'.

Should gameloft shenanigans imply gameloft?

Why in Tartarus does sparkler imply amethyst star? That’s super dumb, they are expressly two different Ponies regardless of how hard some people used to get (extremely niche) fanon confused with Amethyst Star’s actual canon name.

@TexasUberAlles  
Can you fucking try not be be an ass all the time?

@The Smiling Pony  
Can’t believe I’m agreeing with you.
 
@TexasUberAlles  
It’s so people who don’t know the canon name can find it, plus to not have to retag over a thousand tags.

Anyone feel up to ending a arguments over the tags in the below Webm?  

@Meanlucario  
Oh god, not that argument over “trollestia” being bad and not a fun nickname just for her to be joking around…
 
Anmyway, just report the BP for tag warring.

@Prof.NightJack  
Afraid so.

@Meanlucario  
I’ve had that argument many time.  
I don’t get how they think that “troll” can’t be used in a joking/affectionate manner at all and any time it’s used it’s to insult her.

@Prof.NightJack  
Now you see why I wanted someone else to take care of this one.

@Meanlucario  
Thanks for bringing it up, tag wars never turn out well. Though your best bet to get staff involved is submitting a report, like NightJack said. Cheers!

@ArmadilloEater  
Thanks, I’ll try to remember to report it next time.

DO you think the “busty starlight glimmer” + “busty sunset shimmer” tags belong on this image?
 

@ice1517  
No.

@ice1517  
I legit wouldn’t have even noticed they had breasts at all if you didn’t mention it.

@ice1517  
No. Crap like that is part of the reason for the change in the names of those tags in the first place.

@Zeb  
sorry D:

@ice1517  
…Why sorry? o.0