"full comic" , "all in one" and compilation implications

Background Pony #84DB

As someone pointed out in this comment

full comic should imply all in one and compilation

and all in one should imply compilation

Unless anything speaks against that?

Posted 4 years ago Report

Link Quote Reply

Yoshimon1

yay(){ yay|yay & };yay

I’d vote for a rework of that tag (or at least a clarification when to use it) instead of the implications.

Full comic is misleading and doesn’t actually apply to all full comics. For example, it doesn’t seem to get used for 2 panel comic at all. But if we start doing that now, then the compilation implication would definitely be wrong.
There are quite a few pictures tagged with it where every comic panel is from the same source post, like >>1870181 and >>1749904. IMO splitting panels up to post it on Tumblr or Twitter doesn’t make it a compilation when you put them back together. And then there are the “full” comics that actually were posted as just a single image, like >>986825.
Do we actually need both full comic and all in one? I can’t see any difference. We could just alias them.

Posted 4 years ago Report

Link Quote Reply

Background Pony #84DB

@Yoshimon1
About

– Do we actually need both full comic and all in one? I can’t see any difference. We could just alias them.

My understanding would be that all in one also applies to NON comics, while full comic is specifically only for comics but not for things that are none
This for example could get all in one but not full comic, because it’s not a comic
>>1466573 (slightly nsfw)
But yeah, debatable if all 3 tags are needed

Posted 4 years ago Report

Link Quote Reply

Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!

Sky Railroad Merch Shop!

Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!