Unpopular opinion time

@PaperBagPony  
Wing Bling
 

I find it remarkable easy to forget that Daring Do is a Rainbow Dash recolour. I don’t know what that says about me.

@Mr grump  
The thought of that alone amuses me

@gingerninja666  
They’ve mostly done a pretty good job at making her stand out. If she was similar in personality, it wouldn’t have worked as well

Sunset Shimmer is the most overrated character in human history.

@UserAccount  
Oh please - she’s not even the most overrated in FIM history.

@Latecomer  
She is to me. There’s nothing good about her.

@Latecomer
 
I’d say only Maud is more overrated.

@Spinny  
Though she’s my best pony, Fluttershy has consistently come top of polls throughout the fandom’s existence. The same polls that Rarity generally comes out near the bottom. I might possibly suggest that’s a little undeserved.
 
…Luna wins a special award for being ludicriously overrated in the early years, though her fandom has settled down considerably.

@Latecomer  
I say that towards Derpy

@ILoveMyoozik  
I guess, though I have an affection for her. She was a great fanfiction character, and I feel it’s sad that so many people now only remember her as a meme.

If we’re talking overall, I’d say Fluttershy. There was a time she was like a sacred cow, guaranteed to top any best character polls, bad-mouthing her was a death sentence, and the primary reason so many people hated Gilda was she yelled at Fluttershy. She’s died down a lot lately though, so currently I’d say it’s a tossup between Maud, Starlight, and Luna :D

@Philweasel
 
Fluttershy was definitely overrated in the early days, but in later seasons, she really ended up standing out by simply not regressing in the same way most of her friends did. Hell, that was evident just by season 9 alone.
 
Applejack, though? Most underrated character in history. ;P

@Philweasel  
I’m not denying that a lot of people in the fandom gravitated towards her early on, but I just can’t relate to her in any way. I’m not saying she’s a bad character in a way, but she doesn’t do it for me and I think she gets overexposed when it comes to the fandom overall.

I want to kill Marble Pie!!! What a godawful character she is!!!! How lazy could the writers possibly be to just make her a Fluttershy clone?!!?!!??!??!?!
 
So horrible and extra shameful because Limestone is fucking sexy!!!!!!!!!

@UserAccount  
I at least agree with the implication that Limey needed an episode of her own :D

The problem with Fluttershy is that in the show, she’s almost always gonna have the moral highground over whoever she’s paired with. She always has to be right, even if the show’s reasoning is shit or episodes suffer for it. Bats! and Daring Doubt come to mind

@Badumsquish  
Better yet, one with both sisters at the helm

@Badumsquish  
Yeah, she should’ve had an episode with Star Tracker where he accidentally pissed her off and she took revenge on him for it.
 
@Kiryu-Chan  
She was in the moral right in Bats.

I’d say Stellar Flare.

@ILoveMyoozik  
I honestly would have been fine if both Pie sisters actually got an episode, as it would have at laste helped me like them a little more.

@Mildgyth  
Who

@Broken Adam
 
Sunburst’s mother.

@The Equestrian Zodiac  
I would’ve appreciated Limestome more myself

@AC97  
I hate that character.